Child care during the coronavirus pandemic is very different than ever before.
Temperature checks, hand-washing and face masks are constants at preschools and child care centers across America. Class sizes have limits, and some lunchrooms and common areas are off-limits. The safety measures pose a constant reminder to families: These are not normal times.
As parts of the country tiptoe back toward more normal routines, working parents are desperate for child care. Still, they must weigh the risks of sending their children outside the safety of their homes to be cared for by someone else.
The big question remains: Is it safe?
“We don’t know,” said Danette Glassy, a Seattle-area pediatrician. “There’s no scientific answer to that question until we have more time under our belts.”
Parents and day care providers should consider the size of the outbreak in their area and commit to health and safety measures recommended by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The goal: Reduce exposure to the virus wherever and wherever possible.
A few blocks from the ocean, Imagination Station in Daytona Beach, Florida, was closed through April. Now children are back at the facility every day – but they interact with the same small groups of classmates, wash their hands over and over and play only with toys that can be easily cleaned. Owner Kim Vukelja said she reopened because her employees wanted to come back to work.
“You’re on a precipice,” she said. “You don’t know which way to go.”
Enrollment is a fraction of what it usually is, but the parents who send their kids each day are grateful for the help.
“Basically, we felt the virus is not going to go anywhere,” Melissa Owens said as she dropped off her 4-year-old daughter, Cora, at Imagination Station. She works for an agency that staffs clinical labs, like the ones that process coronavirus tests. “We just need to be vigilant to make sure our school is going to keep students and parents safe with all the protocols.”
At Imagination Station, those protocols include allowing only one parent to pick up or drop off a child, at assigned and staggered times. A teacher in a mask takes the child’s temperature with a contactless thermometer before he or she can go inside. Children have to deposit their lunchboxes in class-specific bins, so there’s less cross-contamination. They go to the playground, then must wash their hands before they do anything else. Their parents may not come inside.
Children of healthcare providers, first responders and other essential workers have returned to day cares in almost every state, following similar routines.
For many parents, it’s more than a safety decision. It’s an economic one. They cannot work if they cannot send their children somewhere during the day.
Figuring out whether that’s a good idea depends on a lot of factors, said Kate Connor, an assistant professor of pediatrics at Johns Hopkins University and the medical director of the Rales Health Center at KIPP Baltimore, a charter school.
“‘Safe’ is a relative term now,” Connor said. “All of these things are sort of risk-reduction traits essentially, but none of them will be 100%, particularly if COVID is still circulating in the community.”
Providers and parents must consider the infection rate in their community. There are nearly 1.5 million confirmed cases in the USA, but the actual number is probably much higher.
Ideally, where child care providers reopen, there will have been at least two weeks of declining or plateauing hospitalizations and deaths, Connor said. There will be enough testing to identify new cases. And there will be enough people in the public health network who are trained in contact tracing: tracking where infected people have been and notifying people who might have been exposed.
All of that is hard for people to discern on their own. That’s why state-specific information such as stay-at-home orders and guidance on phased reopenings is so important. Every day, state officials announce updates and ease restrictions based on the trends they see.
Still, if a state is reopening, that doesn’t necessarily mean everything is fine.
“You will still have to always assume that the person you’re interacting with could have COVID,” Glassy said.
It’s unclear how big a role children may play in the spread of the virus to adults. Adults and children with compromised immune systems or preexisting conditions are always at increased risk.
For families who need to start using child care again, Glassy and Connor advise checking with the provider about what safety measures it has in place.
Depending on the outbreak in their area, states take guidelines from the CDC and translate them into regulations for operation. They have some common traits.
Commonly, class sizes are limited and kept to a ratio of nine children to one adult. The ratio is lower for younger children or infants, and some states, such as Ohio, created lower class-size limits for children of all ages.
Child care providers should wear masks, especially when in close contact with younger children. Providers should screen children for symptoms when they arrive each day by taking their temperature or asking about symptoms. Children and adults who have any symptoms associated with coronavirus should stay home. Everyone should wash their hands – very often.
Social distancing guidelines are the hardest for child care centers to reinforce. Outside members of the same household, the CDC recommends staying 6 feet away from other people.
That becomes difficult in small facilities where one adult cares for multiple children. Young kids by nature play in close quarters with each other. It’s even good for their development.
“This is really hard because this is sort of the fabric of what child care centers do,” Connor said.
Under the new coronavirus reality, many child care providers try to keep children around a small group of the same people each day. Separate classes no longer have lunches together at a long table or mix on the playground. Providers try to be strict about the other protective measures, knowing social distancing will be a struggle.
In Sommerville, New Jersey, Tirusha Dave took a few extra measures when she opened Ellie’s Academy for essential workers. She requires her students to change their shoes when they get in, and she asked her workers to limit food deliveries to the facility.
She’s required to send attendance logs, temperature logs and information about possible exposure for her students to the state regularly.
Vukelja, in Daytona Beach, doesn’t have to meet those tracking requirements – but she had her families and employees sign a contract that they would minimize contact with people outside their families and the preschool.
Asking questions about a facility’s protective measures becomes even more important when parents aren’t allowed into the facilities where they send their children. Day care tours have been suspended as a way to keep out unnecessary people. Dave said some of her families have never even met the teacher who is with their children all day.
“They’re leaving their kids somewhere where they can’t even have a tour of the building,” Dave said. “It’s a matter of trust that they have, that they’re handing their child off to somebody who’s healthy and safe and secure.”
Providing child care during a pandemic comes at a cost. There’s the purchase of protective equipment, the limits to class sizes, declining enrollment and therefore revenue – all in a business with already notoriously low profit margins. As some centers regroup and reopen, others stay closed. As more parents return to work and need child care again, they could find their day care provider is out of business.
National child care and early education advocates say child care providers need federal aid soon.
An analysis from the National Women’s Law Center estimates Congress would have to allocate $50 billion for less than six months of relief and emergency care. The Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act passed this spring provided money for essential workers to pay for child care, but experts said it’s not enough.
“We are gonna be the biggest part of a comeback, besides people going to work: having a place to put their children that they can trust and feel comfortable with,” said Cindy Lehnhoff, director of the National Child Care Association. “It’s going to be hard if we don’t do something to keep providers like (Imagination Station) open.”
Of the 244,000 licensed child care facilities and in-home care providers in the USA, 60% were forced to close by the pandemic, Lehnhoff said. Of those, 30% to 50% are projected never to reopen. The carnage will leave millions of children without a place to go and thousands of workers without a job. That will put more stress on an already-strained system.
“So far, with so few children, it’s working very well,” Vukelja said. “I don’t know what the fall is going to be like.”
Click here for more information from the CDC.